✨ Now booking first evaluations · Questions? Call (844) 2-GETBOW · calls only

← All evaluations · 🗂️ Copper Safe Storage - McCroskey (2 evaluations) in the directory

Businesses are welcome to print it and display it.❓ Questions about this evaluation?
Bow Service Evaluations · Self-storage

Copper Safe Storage - McCroskey

📍 2216 McCroskey Island Rd, Sevierville, TN 37876

OverallBelow expectations
Visit dateNovember 2026 (as a renter, after the change of owners)
ArrivalOngoing renter
Report No.BSE-2026-0006
EvaluatorBow
🎉 Bow's pick: just for fun
Nobody asked or paid for this visit. Bow chose to go.
✏️ Correction
Corrected November 2026: the value limit in the rental agreement is $5,000, as the company told me. My original review said about $2,500.
Summary

These storage units used to be run by Affordable Storage Guys, which was an amazing company. I had no problem with the facility being sold. The problems started after: a rental agreement that took about three weeks to arrive, a nearly month-long back-and-forth over a value limit in that agreement, losing the 24-hour access we had before, and an extra $25 a month for that access that I was only told about after doing everything they asked. New owners can set new policies, but confusing agreements, inconsistent explanations and fees not shared upfront are not reasonable.

Ratings
Rental agreementBelowTook about three weeks to arrive after the new owners announced it.
Clear answersBelowThe agreement limited stored value (the company later told me the limit is $5,000) without written approval, but I was told it was "just a recommendation" and never got the approval in writing.
24-hour accessBelowRemoved after the change of owners; getting it back required a business license and then an extra $25 a month.
Fees told upfrontBelowThe $25 a month fee was only mentioned after I had already bought the business license.
Photos
The storage units at 2216 McCroskey Island Rd (Bow's photo).
The storage units at 2216 McCroskey Island Rd (Bow's photo).
Problem 1: The rental agreement

The new owners emailed to say they had taken over, where to send payments, and that a new rental agreement would be sent. One week passed, then two. When I called, I was told they were working on it. It finally arrived around the third week. The agreement asked for an inventory of everything in the unit and had a clause limiting the value of stored belongings without written approval (my first review said about $2,500; the company later told me the limit is $5,000). I'm self-insured, so I asked for written approval to go over that amount, because my insurance company could question coverage if I didn't follow the agreement. I was told it was "just a recommendation." For nearly a month I kept asking for written authorization; they said it wasn't an issue because I was self-insured but didn't give the written approval I asked for. Eventually they emailed that it was only a recommendation and up to the tenant, even though the agreement says otherwise. I kept all the emails and documents.

Problem 2: 24-hour access

Under the previous owners we had 24-hour access, and the new owners took it away. Their agreement said we could request 24-hour access, so I called and explained that, for personal reasons, I sometimes organize my unit at unusual hours, and that I sell at flea markets and sometimes need items around 5 AM. I was told I needed a business license. So I went to the courthouse and paid $15 for one, just to access my storage unit.

Problem 3: A surprise $25 a month

After getting the license, I called back thinking we were done. I was told I still had to submit a request for approval, and that 24-hour access costs an extra $25 per month. So I lost access I had before, was told to get a business license, paid for it, and only afterward learned it would cost another $300 a year to reach my own belongings outside regular hours. That should have been mentioned the first time I called.

My honest opinion

I understand new ownership means new policies. But confusing agreements, weeks of back-and-forth, inconsistent explanations and extra fees that weren't shared with me upfront are not reasonable. I never had these problems with the previous owners, and I miss them. Based on my experience, I would not recommend this facility right now.

My advice to renters
  • Read your rental agreement before signing
  • Ask about every fee, including access hours
  • Get everything in writing
  • Make sure you understand exactly what you are agreeing to
Ideas to make it even better
Clear agreementsIf a limit is only a recommendation, say so in the agreement, and give written approval when a tenant asks.
Fees upfrontShare every requirement and fee for 24-hour access in the first conversation.
Faster paperworkSend new agreements to existing tenants promptly after a change of owners.
This evaluation is Bow's own personal opinion of one visit as a regular guest. It is not a professional, health or safety inspection.
BowPOTTER SERVICE
🛈 Not an inspection. Bow Service Evaluations are customer-experience visits by a regular guest. They are not health inspections, food safety or restaurant inspections, or any kind of official, licensing or safety inspection, and a Gold Star is not a government or health rating. Every evaluation is Bow's own personal opinion, not a professional or official rating. If Bow notices something that looks like a real health or safety concern, Bow will report it to the proper agency (for example, the local health department) so they can look into it.