Copper Safe Storage - McCroskey
📍 2216 McCroskey Island Rd, Sevierville, TN 37876
Nobody asked or paid for this visit. Bow chose to go.
Corrected November 2026: the value limit in the rental agreement is $5,000, as the company told me. My original review said about $2,500.
Follow-up: how the company responded (BSE-2026-0007)
These storage units used to be run by Affordable Storage Guys, which was an amazing company. I had no problem with the facility being sold. The problems started after: a rental agreement that took about three weeks to arrive, a nearly month-long back-and-forth over a value limit in that agreement, losing the 24-hour access we had before, and an extra $25 a month for that access that I was only told about after doing everything they asked. New owners can set new policies, but confusing agreements, inconsistent explanations and fees not shared upfront are not reasonable.
| Rental agreement | Below | Took about three weeks to arrive after the new owners announced it. |
| Clear answers | Below | The agreement limited stored value (the company later told me the limit is $5,000) without written approval, but I was told it was "just a recommendation" and never got the approval in writing. |
| 24-hour access | Below | Removed after the change of owners; getting it back required a business license and then an extra $25 a month. |
| Fees told upfront | Below | The $25 a month fee was only mentioned after I had already bought the business license. |

The new owners emailed to say they had taken over, where to send payments, and that a new rental agreement would be sent. One week passed, then two. When I called, I was told they were working on it. It finally arrived around the third week. The agreement asked for an inventory of everything in the unit and had a clause limiting the value of stored belongings without written approval (my first review said about $2,500; the company later told me the limit is $5,000). I'm self-insured, so I asked for written approval to go over that amount, because my insurance company could question coverage if I didn't follow the agreement. I was told it was "just a recommendation." For nearly a month I kept asking for written authorization; they said it wasn't an issue because I was self-insured but didn't give the written approval I asked for. Eventually they emailed that it was only a recommendation and up to the tenant, even though the agreement says otherwise. I kept all the emails and documents.
Under the previous owners we had 24-hour access, and the new owners took it away. Their agreement said we could request 24-hour access, so I called and explained that, for personal reasons, I sometimes organize my unit at unusual hours, and that I sell at flea markets and sometimes need items around 5 AM. I was told I needed a business license. So I went to the courthouse and paid $15 for one, just to access my storage unit.
After getting the license, I called back thinking we were done. I was told I still had to submit a request for approval, and that 24-hour access costs an extra $25 per month. So I lost access I had before, was told to get a business license, paid for it, and only afterward learned it would cost another $300 a year to reach my own belongings outside regular hours. That should have been mentioned the first time I called.
I understand new ownership means new policies. But confusing agreements, weeks of back-and-forth, inconsistent explanations and extra fees that weren't shared with me upfront are not reasonable. I never had these problems with the previous owners, and I miss them. Based on my experience, I would not recommend this facility right now.
- Read your rental agreement before signing
- Ask about every fee, including access hours
- Get everything in writing
- Make sure you understand exactly what you are agreeing to